top of page

Carla Lockhart says UK–EU deal fails to remove Irish Sea border or address Windsor Framework

Writer: Love Ballymena
Love Ballymena
3 minutes ago
3 min read
Upper Bann MP Carla Lockhart

Upper Bann MP Carla Lockhart


Saturday 21 November 2026


Upper Bann MP Carla Lockhart has criticised the latest UK–EU agreement, warning that it leaves the Irish Sea border in place and fails to address what she describes as the constitutional damage caused by the Windsor Framework.


The independent unionist MP said the proposed changes to food and agricultural trade would not remove the legal arrangements governing the movement of goods from Great Britain into Northern Ireland.


Her intervention follows Friday’s announcement of a UK–EU agreement covering areas including sanitary and phytosanitary (SPS) arrangements, which govern food safety and animal and plant health standards.



Concerns over constitutional impact


Ms Lockhart argued that closer alignment between the UK and EU on food and agricultural standards would extend EU regulatory influence across the United Kingdom rather than resolve unionist objections to the Windsor Framework.


She said:


“Today’s UK–EU deal, which we still haven’t seen in technical detail, does nothing to undo the fundamental constitutional vandalism still being inflicted by the Windsor Framework and the resulting Irish Sea border.


“An SPS deal which subjects the whole UK to the same slavish subjugation Northern Ireland already faces, with EU law imposed upon us, does nothing to repair the constitutional harm. It simply extends that harm to the whole of the United Kingdom.”



The proposed SPS arrangements are intended to reduce trade barriers by aligning relevant UK and EU rules. However, Ms Lockhart maintained that regulatory alignment alone would not resolve the constitutional objections she has raised.


Legal framework remains central to objections


The MP highlighted EU Regulation 2017/625, which governs official controls on food, feed, animals and other regulated products, as a central part of her criticism.


She argued that the regulation, alongside the domestic legal provisions giving effect to the Windsor Framework, would continue to underpin controls on goods entering Northern Ireland from Great Britain.


Ms Lockhart said:


“There is no change to EU Regulation 2017/625. It continues to treat Northern Ireland as EU territory for the purposes of official controls and requires checks on goods moving from Great Britain to Northern Ireland. These arrangements continue to have supremacy in domestic law via section 7A of the European Union (Withdrawal) Act, subjugating Article 6 of the Acts of Union, the fundamental foundation of the United Kingdom itself.”



Her comments reflect a wider unionist argument that the Windsor Framework's legal arrangements affect Northern Ireland's constitutional position within the United Kingdom. That interpretation remains politically contested.


Border control posts and proposed legislation


Ms Lockhart said the continued existence of border control posts was evidence that the agreement would not deliver the fundamental changes she believes are necessary.


She stated:


“If the Government were to confront the core issue and make that fundamental change, we could expect it to decommission the offensive border control posts dividing Northern Ireland from the rest of the United Kingdom. This deal will not loosen a solitary screw on those border posts.”


The MP also pointed to legislative proposals brought forward by North Antrim MP Jim Allister KC in the House of Commons and Lord Dodds in the House of Lords, arguing that changes to the underlying legal framework were essential.



She added:


“The only way to remove the Irish Sea border is to deal with the legal architecture that creates it.”


Concerns raised over students and future trade


Ms Lockhart also criticised the prospect of further UK alignment with EU rules, arguing that Britain should pursue an independent international trading policy.


She raised separate concerns about suggestions of reduced tuition fees for EU students and the possible implications of increased youth mobility between the UK and EU.


The MP said:


“I am also concerned at suggestions that the Government is considering cutting tuition fees for EU students but not for our own students here in the UK. There are also suggestions that this could bring significantly more young people from the EU at a time when our own young people already struggle to get university places and jobs. Putting young people from the EU ahead of our own would hobble the next generation.”


These concerns relate to potential future arrangements rather than confirmed changes to tuition fees or university admissions.



Further paper promised on Windsor Framework


Ms Lockhart said she intends to publish a paper next week examining what she considers the continuing failures of the Windsor Framework and the impact of the Irish Sea border.


She also criticised the previous Safeguarding the Union agreement, which was presented by the UK Government as a means of addressing unionist concerns about Northern Ireland's place within the UK internal market.


The MP concluded:


“Next week I will publish the paper I promised, setting out where I believe the Windsor Framework continues to fail Northern Ireland, and how the Irish Sea border continues to affect us. The Safeguarding the Union deal embedded that border. It didn’t even soften it, much less remove it.”



bottom of page