Burnham says hard Brexit has failed Britain as he sets out terms for new EU deal


UK Prime Minister Andy Burnham
Monday 16 November 2026
Prime Minister Andy Burnham has declared that Britain has lost more than it has gained from a decade of Brexit, setting out the conditions under which his government would agree a new deal with the European Union at a summit in Brussels on Friday.
In a major foreign policy speech at the Lord Mayor’s Banquet in London on Monday evening, Mr Burnham said the existing Brexit settlement was failing to deliver the economic improvements voters had expected, arguing that closer cooperation with Europe could help reduce living costs, remove barriers for businesses and strengthen economic growth.
He said a proposed agreement could add up to 0.4% to UK GDP, although its final terms have yet to be agreed. The Prime Minister indicated that legislation could be introduced to Parliament next week if the negotiations succeed.
Three tests for a new EU agreement
Mr Burnham said any agreement reached at Friday’s UK–EU Summit would have to satisfy three conditions before receiving government approval.
It must remain consistent with the government's manifesto commitments and negotiating red lines, improve the existing Brexit arrangements, and deliver measurable benefits to communities that have experienced economic decline.
The third requirement forms part of what the Prime Minister calls the Makerfield Test, named after his constituency, which voted to leave the EU in the 2016 referendum.
Explaining the approach, he said:
“It is a new approach to government - judging all policies through the lens of our least well-off communities and whether they will make life better there or worse.”
The Prime Minister identified reducing the cost of the weekly shop, cutting business bureaucracy, lowering electricity bills and improving cooperation on illegal immigration as areas where an agreement could make a difference.
He said:
“If the deal delivers all of this, and I believe it can, it will easily pass the Makerfield Test and I will agree it.”
A direct challenge to the Brexit settlement
The speech marked an unusually direct assessment of Britain's departure from the EU, with Mr Burnham arguing that the economic and political promises associated with Brexit had not been fulfilled.
He acknowledged that some sectors, including financial services and technology, had adapted successfully, but said others had suffered under the arrangements established after Britain's departure.
“The hard Brexit we were given is not good enough for Britain,” he told guests.
Mr Burnham cited the Office for Budget Responsibility's assessment that Brexit would leave the British economy around 4% smaller than it would otherwise have been, alongside other estimates suggesting a larger impact of up to 8% of GDP.
He insisted that his approach was not intended to reopen the referendum argument, but to respond to changing economic and security circumstances.
“This is not about re-running the arguments of 2016, as I said at the by-election. The world has changed so much since then,” he said.
What the proposals could mean for Northern Ireland
The proposed changes will be of particular interest to Northern Ireland businesses, which operate under post-Brexit trading arrangements that differ from those applying in Great Britain.
Under the Windsor Framework, Northern Ireland continues to follow certain EU rules governing goods, while remaining part of the United Kingdom's internal market. This creates a distinctive trading position, particularly for businesses moving goods between Great Britain, Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland.
Any UK–EU agreement that reduces regulatory differences or administrative barriers could therefore have implications for businesses operating across those markets. However, the Prime Minister's speech did not set out specific changes to the Windsor Framework or establish how the proposed deal would affect Northern Ireland.
The detailed terms of any agreement will be important in determining whether businesses and consumers in Northern Ireland benefit, and whether existing trading procedures would change.
Government promises wider foreign policy reset
Beyond Europe, Mr Burnham outlined what he described as a fundamental repositioning of British foreign policy, arguing that the UK must rebuild international relationships and pursue its economic interests through closer cooperation with allies.
He pledged continued support for Ukraine, stronger European security and NATO cooperation, and renewed diplomatic engagement in the Middle East.
The Prime Minister also announced plans for structured dialogue with Commonwealth partners during 2027 over the legacy of slavery, while ruling out the payment of reparations.
He said Britain would use its G20 presidency next year to pursue greater international cooperation on economic security, development finance and artificial intelligence, including work towards a proposed Manchester Compact on AI.
Longer-term relationship with Europe
Although the immediate focus is Friday's summit, Mr Burnham signalled that the government intends to explore broader options for Britain's future relationship with the EU.
He said discussions with European partners would begin after the summit, with potential arrangements and government assessments presented ahead of decisions in the next Parliament.
The Prime Minister stressed that his government would not cross its existing negotiating red lines before a general election.
For now, the immediate test will be whether Friday's negotiations produce an agreement that can deliver the practical economic improvements he has promised. For households and businesses facing continued pressure from living costs, the significance of any reset will depend not simply on improved relations with Brussels, but on what changes in the prices they pay and the conditions under which they trade.



